jump to navigation

Court Protects Anonymous Blogs October 7, 2005

Posted by Tycho in Chatter.
comments closed

In an extremely unique and pertinent topic, the Detroit Free Press reports on a recent case presented to the Delaware Supreme Court where Smyrna councilman Patrick Cahill had petitioned the lower court to reveal the identities of four anonymous bloggers who, among other charges, had caused him “obvious mental deterioration.”  The comments were posted on a site operated by Independent Newspapers Inc., who publishes the Delaware State News.  In June of this year, the lower court agreed with Cahill’s allegations of defamation and ordered Comcast to reveal the bloggers’ identities.

Today, however, the Delaware Supreme Court overturned that decision by the lower court, stating that Cahill’s allegations were lacking in proof.  In boldly upholding our First Amendment right to free and anonymous speech, Chief Justice Myron Steele wrote:

“We are concerned that setting the standard too low will chill potential posters from exercising their First Amendment right to speak anonymously.  The possibility of losing anonymity in a future lawsuit could intimidate anonymous posters into self-censoring their comments or simply not commenting at all.”

That possibility of losing our freedom of anonymous speech is very real, believe me.  Part of the reason I’m so excited about this blog the allure of speaking to an audience with relative anonymity.  My pseudonym protects both me and my words.  If you, my readers, knew who I was, I would be much more hesitant to openly speak my mind.  Instead, I would be constantly aware that those whom I might speak out against could later use my words against me, and as such, I would choose to restrain my speech.  The idea that those who feel criticised by our words can litigate us into the open is chilling at best.

“Given the context, no reasonable person could have interpreted these statements as being anything other than opinion. … The statements are, therefore, incapable of a defamatory meaning.”

This ruling by the Delaware Supreme Court, while limited in its scope, certainly helps set the precedent in protecting those of us who choose to publicly speak on the Internet.  It emboldens us writers to openly express our thoughts and minds while knowing that what we write is relatively protected.  Words are a very powerful tool, and today, it is truly reassuring to know that we can continue to use them as we see fit.

“I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it.” — Voltaire

Please Help Save “Arrested Development” October 4, 2005

Posted by Tycho in Television.
comments closed

Arrested Development

The world of television is a vast and desolate place.  Most shows are not worth your time, but there are some, such as Fox’s “Arrested Development,” that simply deserve to be admired and watched.  As what often happens with wonderful programs, for two years Fox didn’t know what to do with the show.  Combining smart writing with sharp delivery, it truly is one of today’s best and brightest satires.  The narration by Ron Howard is priceless, and the six-time Emmy winning show just oozes wit.

Now in its third season, “Arrested Development” is unfortunately on the rocks.  Although better than ever, Fox simply cannot do this show justice.  They’ve moved it countless times, alienating their audience in the process.  Indeed, the show was nearly cancelled last season if not for the clamor of its ardent fans.  Only the most enthusiastic have been able to keep up with the changing timeslot, and nevertheless, yesterday it struggled to come in at 13th in the ratings.  And while the show’s contract for this season is a full 22 episodes, Fox could easily pull the plug at any moment.

There’s only one thing we must do to help the show — and that is tune in and watch!  Mondays, at 8/7c pm.  The next episode is on October 31 — Halloween.  Watch it, tape it, TiVo it, DVR it.  Whatever it takes.  Please, faithful reader, from someone who wishes only the very best for you, please help save “Arrested Development!”

Just a sample of its hilarity, from uh-NAL-ruh-pist Tobias Fünke, M.D.:

Arrested Development